Sense & Sensibility (Marvel Illustrated)

As part of the Sense & Sensibility Bicentenary Challenge
I set for one of my tasks to read the Marvel Illustrated version of Jane Austen's Sense & Sensibility.

Having read the original earlier in the year, as well as treating myself to rewatching of two of the three adaptations, the story was very fresh in my mind, which means that I was painfully aware when the adapters, Nancy Butler and Sonny Liew, deviated from the original or inserted their interpretation of what I saw as Austen ambiguities in the story.

Overall, I enjoyed the graphic version. The drawings were fun and fresh. Unlike the Northanger Abbey graphic version that I so enjoyed in Gothic Classics: Graphic Classics Volume 14, I didn't think this rendition was superior to other adaptations (video or otherwise). Where it fell down was when the adaptors added their own language, which I found rather wooden.

Again, I think Marianne was a bit over-simplified as a highly emotional self-centered twit instead of a self-absorbed, committed artist, but that's a bias that runs deep on my part. I was also amused that Margaret and Edward once again play-act at piracy; Emma Thompson's fleshing out of Margaret has apparently become part of the canon. They also fiddled with Mrs. Dashwood's perception of Edward's and Elinor's attachment whilst at Norwood, and mucked with the timing and motivation around her staying at and then quitting Norland. They also didn't portray Willoughby rejecting Marianne in London properly--why change a perfectly good scene like that?

Lucy was depicted perfectly, however, and Colonel Brandon definitely had a David Morrissey look about him. And, they allowed Elinor to feel sorry for Willoughby after he visits her at Cleveland while Marianne is ill. I know that many readers cannot forgive Willoughby for his selfish actions in the story, but Elinor does feel sorry for him and I'm glad they didn't cut that part out as others have.

Despite my nit-picking it was as good an adaptation as the two latest film/video versions, and better than the old BBC version. I liked it enough to offer it up for a giveaway on Austen's birthday, December 16...so stay tuned if you would like to win a slightly used copy!

From Prada to Nada: Sense & Sensibility Bicentenary Challenge Update

Back in April I belatedly signed up for the challenge to focus my Austen-only eyes on her first published novel, Sense and Sensibility, in honor of the 200th year since its first publication.

Here's what I committed to and how I'm doing...

☑ Reread Sense and Sensibility
☑ Read The Three Weissmans of Westport, by Cathleen Schine
☑ Rewatch the Ang Lee adaptation, aka the Emma Thompson adaptation
☐ Rewatch the 2008 BBC adaptation
☐ Watch I have Found it (Kandukondain Kandukondain)
☑ Watch From Prada to Nada
☐ Reread Sense and Sensibility: The Screenplay and Diaries
☐ Read Sense and Sensibility (Marvel Illustrated)
☐ Read Willoughby’s Return, by Jane Odiwe
☑ Write S&S-inspired short story for the Jane Austen Made Me Do It competition
☐ Attend the 2011 JASNA AGM in Fort Worth in October

I watched the Emma Thompson/Ang Lee adaptation after finishing a reread of the novel in the spring, and enjoyed it as usual. Also as usual, I still found myself gnashing my teeth over Thompson's exclusion of the Willoughby visit to Cleveland near the end of the book. It is a crucial scene in my opinion, and the movie is flawed for omitting it.

I am looking forward to getting my copy of Thompson's Sense and Sensibility: The Screenplay and Diaries back from the JASNA friend to whom I lent it and reading it over the summer.

In May, I watched From Prada to Nada. When I first heard about this movie, I was pretty excited about it--I tend to like LA Latino movies (e.g., Tortilla Soup) and felt that the plot line had potential in a modern adaptation. Then my teenaged daughters heard that I wanted to see it and gave me all sorts of grief about how silly it looked. But, I had made a commitment to the Challenge gods, and so rented it from NetFlix.

I have to say it was kinda fun. I absolutely love the song, Cielito Lindo, which was featured early in the movie, so I spent the week after watching the movie humming the song. My favorite version of the song is that by The Three Tenors. Unfortunately, for most people my age, it will be forever associated with Fritos corn chips, since it was the jingle theme music during our formative years.

Back to the movie, as is typical in these modern retellings of S&S, the Elinor character is a stick-in-the-mud, beauty-behind-glasses and the Marianne character is a flighty, shallow, narcissistic knock-out. The Edward character was a rather cute lawyer with typical Edward dithering, his sister was an over-the-top gold-digging bitch, and the John Dashwood character was a long-lost (or rather recently found) brother who turned out not that bad after all.

My favorite character was the Colonel Brandon character, who was a barrio artiste who definitely outshone the Willoughby professor character from our first encounter. Strong, silent, and sensitive, he champions Marianne throughout and definitely was the romantic lead, leaving Edward in the dust...as usual.

My second favorite character was the girls' aunt with whom they go to live when thrown out of their father's house after death--she plays the Mrs. Jennings and Sir John Middleton part collectively and was earthy, practical, maternal, and family.

What I ended up liking about this movie is the theme of family--embracing one's roots and celebrating life together. I'm not sure it's a theme I necessarily associate with S&S itself, but it ended up making From Prada to Nada work.

From Prada to Nada didn't have the script that Clueless had and won't have the staying power in the hearts of Janeites, but in this year of S&S, it is definitely worth watching...if only to be reminded of what a pretty song Cielito Lindo is.

The Sense and Sensibility Bicentenary Challenge 2011

I always seem to be the last one to the party, but that doesn't mean I don't enjoy the party while I'm there. Last December, Laurel Ann of Austenprose announced the The Sense and Sensibility Bicentenary Challenge 2011 and I'm only now getting around to signing up for it, now that I have two challenges for it under my belt.

In the proverbial nutshell:

2011 is a celebratory year for Jane Austen and her legion of fans. It marks the bicentenary of her first published novel, Sense and Sensibility. Since 1811, we have been enjoying her romantic, dramatic and witty story filled with divergent characters – the Dashwood sisters: cool, practical Elinor and emotional, impulsive Marianne, and the men in their lives: stoic Edward Ferrars, staid Colonel Brandon and rakish Willoughby. There is much to praise in this novel which has inspired many movie adaptations, book sequels and spinoffs.

I think I will go for the Disciple level (5-8 selections), though I may make it to the Aficionada level (9-12 selections)

What do I plan to do?

☑ Reread Sense and Sensibility
☑ Read The Three Weissmans of Westport, by Cathleen Schine
☑ Rewatch the Ang Lee adaptation, aka the Emma Thompson adaptation
☑ Rewatch the 2008 BBC adaptation
☐ Watch I have Found it (Kandukondain Kandukondain)
☑ Watch From Prada to Nada
☐ Reread Sense and Sensibility: The Screenplay and Diaries
☑ Read Sense and Sensibility (Marvel Illustrated)
☐ Read Willoughby’s Return, by Jane Odiwe
☑ Write S&S-inspired short story for the Jane Austen Made Me Do It competition
☑ Attend the 2011 JASNA AGM in Fort Worth in October

The last two weren't options that Laurel Ann provided, but I felt inspired :)