I just finished a reread of Bleak House by the incomparable Charles Dickens. I first read it in college, close to 50 years ago, and I've read it a few times since, but I think this go-round was the most enjoyable.
I remembered the basic outline of the plot, but that was about it. It was like meeting all the characters--the insufferable, the delightful, the pitiful, the stalwart, the noble, and the ignoble--for the first time.
Here's the blurb from GoodReads:
Widely regarded as Dickens’s masterpiece, Bleak House centers on the generations-long lawsuit Jarndyce and Jarndyce, through which “whole families have inherited legendary hatreds.” Focusing on Esther Summerson, a ward of John Jarndyce, the novel traces Esther’s romantic coming-of-age and, in classic Dickensian style, the gradual revelation of long-buried secrets, all set against the foggy backdrop of the Court of Chancery. Mixing romance, mystery, comedy, and satire, Bleak House limns the suffering caused by the intricate inefficiency of the law.
I agree with this blurb mostly. However, the book is about so much more than "the suffering caused by the inefficiency of the law." It is about loving your neighbor and doing the right thing.
Let's look at the categories of characters.
The insufferable - Mrs. Jellyby (neglects her family and home while frantically working to Christianize the natives of Africa), Mrs. Snagsby (relentlessly persecutes poor little Jo, the road sweeper, suspeects her husband of all sorts of infidelities and admires the odious Mr. Chadband, the sanctimonious preacher. These are the hypocrites, who profess to be god-fearing but are actually mean and mean-spirited.
Mr. Vohles is a lawyer hired by Richard Carstone. Unlike the other lawyer featured in the story, Mr. Tulkinghorn, he is motivated by money and he coldly sets up getting as much as he can, using the excuse that he has three daughters and a father to support. He is the other side of the coin from Mrs. Jellyby, who neglects her family completely. Both are insufferable.
The delightful - I love Caddie Jellyby so much, the long-suffering daughter of Mrs. Jellyby who finds her own way in life as devoted wife, mother, daughter (to her poor father), daughter-in-law (to the selfish but essentially harmless but model of deportment Mr. Turveydrop), and dancing instructress! The gentleman by the name of Guppy is also delightful--he is a law clerk, and earnest and eager to be upwardly mobile, but a good sort in the end.
I also put Charlie, the orphan girl who ends up as Esther's maid, in the delightful category. Despite Esther's best efforts, she never can grasp the rudiments of grammar, but she is loyal, loving, hardworking, tender, and a bit quirky, making her more than just a paragon of virtue.
Miss Flite is also delightful. Some might say she is pitiful, being so like Richard Carstone, except she isn't. Although she also awaits a settlement, she has not lost her sense of self, and she is not blind to the dangers of expectations, the way Richard is. I love her flighty ways, her love of birds, and her regard for others.
The pitiful - both Lady Dedlock and Sir Leister sadly fall into this category. She is bored to death, and he is devoted to her and life without her is unimaginable. I cannot say more without sharing spoilers so suffice it to say that I found Lady Dedlock's story to be heart-wrenching.
Jo is, of course, part of the pitiful crowd. He seems to function as a litmus test: if someone cares for Jo and tries to help him, then that is a good character with a good soul and a heart that loves its neighbor. If a character despises Jo, then rest assured, Dickens is going to show that character to be mean, hypocritical, and basically scum.
Richard Carstone is definitely pitiful--suffering from great expectations, he is the embodiment of the evil that the Court of Chancery lets loose upon the world. He sacrifices his health, his marriage, his reputation, his hope and his joy to the treadmill of expectations. Instead of finding a way to live a productive life, he squanders everything on the hope of a settlement.
The stalwart - Mr. George (Rouncewell), the trooper and shooting gallery owner, accused of murder but so big-hearted and upright that we know Dickens would never let him swing for a crime he coudn't have committed. He befriends Jo and has a veritable stable of people who depend on him.
George comes from stalwart stock. His mother, housekeeper for the Dedlocks, is loyal, strong, fair-minded, and loving. His brother is the same and welcomes George back into the fold without hesitation.
Alan Woodcourt is one of the heroes in Esther's life--a doctor, he is steadfast and cares deeply about his patients and friends. He gives of himself freely and without expectation of anything other than knowing he is doing the best he can.
The Noble - here we get to Esther Summerson, the definitive Dickens paragon of woman. Even when disfigured by smallpox, she earns the love and respect of all who happen to come within her light.
John Jarndyce is the personification of nobleness--the flip side of Richard Carstone, he did not succumb to living in expectation of his court case being settled and favorably. Instead, he found a role for himself as essentially deus ex machina, a benevolent patriarch who knows best and pulls the strings of those around him to cause good things to happen to those who let him know best.
I had to look up when Dickens wrote Bleak House (1852-1853) and when he met and fell in love with Ellen Ternan (1857) because the relationship between John Jarndyce and Esther Summerson more than echoes that of Dickens and Ternan. Perhaps he knew what he was looking for when he met Ellen.
Ada Clare is also noble, sacrificing a comfortable home and role with Mr. Jarndyce and Esther to become the wife of the pitiful Richard Carstone.
The Ignoble - Mr. Tulkinghorn, lawyer to Sir Leister, and the embodiment of everything that is wrong and sick and hurtful about the Court of Chancery. He is cold and calculating. He cares only for the power he has over people--he doesn't even strike me as money-hungry. All he cares about his power, and he cloaks himself in doing his duty to his client. Dickens casts him as a crow or raven, a skulking bird of ill omen (no disrespect to the Corvid family, of which I am an ardent fan!).
The entire Smallweed family, grasping and thoroughly repugnant. They lie, they cheat, they dupe. They are avaricious. They have not an ounce of regard for anyone else, even those within their own miserable family.
I'm going to add one more category to the list I provided above.
The Ambiguous - These are those characters that I haven't really figured out what I think about them. Mr. Krook, the rag and bottle man who spontaneously combusts. He is Mrs. Smallweed's brother, and is a hoarder by trade and by nature--not sure if he is a good guy or a bad guy or just a plot point (he has the documents that Mr. Tulkinghorn wants in order to secure his power over Lady Dedlock).
Nemo, the self-named law writer who dies early in the book and who "was very good" to Jo is another character I cannot quite peg. He was good to Jo and so passes the litmus test, but I would love to know his backstory and how he came to be in the sad state in which we find him.
---------------------------------------------
I have to agree that Bleak House is a masterpiece. It is a complicated story, a dark story full of blind alleys and grief, but ultimately the sun shines and the world turns greener and less muddy and foggy. I won't say it is my favorite Dickens novel, but it is definitely in the top five.
I look forward to rereading it again. I know I will get even more out of it next time!
I just ordered the DVDs via interlibrary loan. I'll let you know how I like it.

















































