Monday, November 24, 2014
Germinal by Émile Zola
Posted by
JaneGS
I received a copy of Émile Zola's novel Germinal years ago as the result of a fellow blogger's giveaway that I won, and I finally read it this Fall. It took me a little while because it is such a dense, somber story, and I needed to take breaks from time to time to cleanse my palate. Fortunately, the book is divided into seven parts, so I read one roughly each week. I ended up being totally blown away by the book, and enthusiastically gave it five Goodreads stars.
I read the Oxford World Classics version, translated from French by Peter Collier, with an introduction, which I just read tonight, by Robert Lethbridge. I found the introduction to be such fun to read--a great way to help me sort through why I responded so warmly to such a bleak book.
And it is bleak. The central character, Etienne Lantier, is a budding socialist who, desperate for work, arrives in a mining village in northern France in the mid-1880s, is hired on, falls in love with his landlord's daughter, and leads the starving, poverty-stricken miners and their families in a strike that ultimately fails and worsens the lot of the villagers. He survives the collapse of a mine that he is working in and survives floods, explosions, and a murderous rival during the twelve days he is trapped underground.
The novel gets its name from one of the springtime months within the French Republican Calendar, and while the novel seems to end on a positive note, with the emergence of springtime after the long cold winter of massive discontent, I couldn't forget that spring and summer ripen and fade into fall and winter.
Despite the bleakness--and it is truly jaw-dropping to read about the horrific conditions under which these French miners existed--I found the book absolutely compelling and the energy contained within it electrifying. I think Lethbridge, in his introduction, expressed what caught me as "the synthesis of the archetypal with the documentary."
Starting first with the documentary, Zola seamlessly wrote of the details of the lives of the mining families as well as their bourgeois mine managers in the context of the intricacies of mine machinery, operation, dynamics, geology, structure and the sights and smells and feelings of being underground. Before he wrote novels, Zola had been a journalist and even though Germinal is the 13th novel in a 20-volume series, he went back to his training as a journalist and thoroughly researched the mining industry in northern France before writing the book.
But detailed descriptions alone do not great literature make, Zola also employed a rich and layered imagery, for example denoting the mine as a beast who must be fed humanity to survive. And from that imagery, Zola was able to tap into our collective remembered stories, the archetypal stories that keep on reappearing down the ages, and that are referred to as myths. Germinal has Demeter/Persephone/Hades, it has the prodigal son, it has Cain and Abel, and it has the maenads (female followers of Dionysus) to name a few, and probably many more that I didn't even recognize.
It's that "synthesis of the archetypal with the documentary" that makes Germinal work. It is utterly believable--it feels like truth.
Final note--if you are moved to adding Germinal to your classics reading list, seek out the translation by Peter Collier. It is absolutely riveting. It sounds modern but at the same time completely realistic for 1880's French miners. It is raw, graphic, often vulgar, and utterly unlike anything else I've read from this time period. I find it surprising that this book wasn't banned for its frank depiction of sex, poverty, drunkenness, and debauchery--perhaps it was. It is also poetic and lyrical. It is as if Zola put his hand on the pulse of humanity and opened a vein.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Love this >> "Zola put his hand on the pulse of humanity and opened a vein." It's so Zola-ish too. :)
ReplyDeleteReading Zola always makes us 'blown-away', I agree, but I liked Germinal most because it has a sense of hope, which Zola's other books lacked of. I also think Etienne is the stronger offspring of Gervaise-Lantier.
I'm glad that you finally read Germinal. Will you read more from the series?
After reading Zola for 7 weeks, I felt his style seeping into my bones! I would love to read more from the series. The little I've read about the series and how Zola integrated his sociological views into the story lines should make for a fascinating reading project.
DeleteI definitely was glad that Germinal ended as it did, with the reemergence of spring. I like to think that Etienne became the leader he dreamed of being in Paris.
I have not read Zola but I really need to.
ReplyDeleteThis looks to be great one to begin with.
Thanks for the translation suggestion. The translator of a book is so important and I find myself putting time and effort into choosing the right one.
Yes, I find the whole translating process so interesting--creative but restrained.
DeleteTherese Raquin was one of my favorite novels the year I read it, and The Ladies' Paradise was wonderful, too. You make meant to pick up Germinal next, but I'm toying with the idea of read the entire cycle in order. Book 1 is on my kindle now...
ReplyDeleteI'm going to have to check out Theerese Raquin--you're the second person to recommend this as my next Zola. I like the title of The Ladies' Paradise.
DeleteReading the entire cycle appeals to me, but it would take a long time unless I gave up reading everything else!
You're a better reader than me. :) While I liked Nana, and I really want to read The Ladies' Paradise, I think I'm going to pass on this particular Zola novel.
ReplyDeleteHave a Happy Thanksgiving! Hope the books you get to read this weekend are as yummy as the food you get to eat.
I haven't heard of Nana--will check that Zola out as well.
DeleteIt's been a crazy, busy 2 weeks, so I am planning on reading the day away on Sat and Sun. Happy Thanksgiving to you as well.
Great review! You're so much more insightful than me -- I didn't get any of the metaphorical references -- and I really glad you liked it. The Belly of Paris was my first read by Zola, which I enjoyed, but Germinal was the book that converted me into a Zola fan. I've now read ten of the Rougon-Macquart series, and I still think it's the best one, though I was also blown away by La Bete Humaine, which is a close second for me. I also loved L'Assommoir. Sadly, though, I didn't much like Nana.
ReplyDeleteThere's also an excellent movie adaptation starring Gerard Depardiu. Sadly, it's only available on VHS, but it's worth seeking out.
I saw there was a movie--glad to hear it's excellent. We still have a VHS player...I think!
Delete