Friday, August 01, 2014

The Secret History

Bennington College, Vermont, author Donna Tartt's alma mater

I finished Donna Tartt's The Secret History last week.  What an interesting book.

I blogged about it a bit when I featured it in a First Chapter-First Paragraph, but it really deserves its own post as well although I seem unable to form a coherent theme to write about so I'll just share some random thoughts.

The Secret History reminded me somewhat of A Separate Peace--a similar academic setting but the characters in The Secret History are older (in college not high school), though not necessarily more mature. And there were shades of Lord of the Flies (another book from my sophomore year of high school)--it's an examination of what happens when children (and the young adults in The Secret History, despite their facade of independence are little more than children) are left to run amok.

It's a fairly dark book, with a motley collection of interesting but mostly amoral characters who drink to excess.  Honestly, with the amount of drinking in this book, I was amazed that any of the main characters remained alive by novel's end.  That makes me sound like an old fuddy-duddy, but I was amazed by how much hard liquor these 20-year-olds could consume without suffering from alcohol poisoning.

It seems I can't read a book anymore without it reminding of another book and this book reminded me of lots of books, apparently...but it did also remind me of Rebecca by Daphne du Maurier in that the hero commits murder and the reader really wants him to get away with it.

I was surprised by the lackluster ending.  Those of you who have read the book might be surprised to find that I found the ending lackluster, but I had envisioned so much more.  ***SPOILER: I thought that the professor of the classics students, Julian, was more involved in the murder. I thought of him as a catalyst or Dionysus figuring who actively but covertly urged his students to experiment with madness.  In the end, he was just a weak man who really viewed his role as more of a hobby than a responsibility.

I did think this a pretty interesting novel--I didn't fall in love with it, and I'm not sure I would reread it--but it was definitely an interesting premise and well-crafted novel.

Here's a good review of it in The Guardian and the comments following the article are worth reading--they run the gambit from "greatest book ever" to "tedious and shallow."  I'm in the ever-ambiguous "interesting" category.

The is the sixth book in my TBR Pile Challenge for 2014.  Making headway!


9 comments:

  1. Jane,

    I read this book about 9 years ago (on the beach in Aruba---LOL) . I remember talking about it to friends about how much I loved it. Bennington, VT is a great town too, when I was younger - I had a friend from there.

    So happy you enjoyed this one. You MUST read her latest The Goldfinch - loved that as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Definitely looking forward to The Goldfinch.

      Bennington, Vt is on my TBV (to be visited) list! I love New England.

      Delete
  2. I really want to read this. Young people running amok is of interest to me. It may sound funny but I am at least partially serious when I say that it reflects some of my experiences which at times were funny but at other times was not funny at all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I eagerly await your thoughts on this. My daughter, who studied Greek in college and just graduated, is reading it now.

      Delete
  3. It's been at least a decade since I read this book, but I loved it! The details are gone, so a reread may be in order... after The Goldfinch which is loaded and waiting on my kindle.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I read this years ago, but I really don't remember much about it.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I read this last year and enjoyed it, though I started to lose interest towards the end and didn't love it the way so many other people do. I also thought the amount of drinking was ridiculous, so I must be a fuddy-duddy too!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I read this a couple years ago and it's one of the few books that I didn't review on the blog because I ended it just hating everyone and feeling cranky about everything that happened. I know so many people that loved it though. It made me feel like maybe I didn't because I was a science major at college. ;)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I liked it but read it long ago and don't remember it well, except for thinking she ran out of steam at the end. I like the comparison to A Separate Piece. When I read The Likeness by Tana French I was reminded of Secret History as well. Have you read her books?

    ReplyDelete